Current:Home > reviewsEntrapment in play as appeals court looks at plot to kidnap Michigan governor -Ascend Wealth Education
Entrapment in play as appeals court looks at plot to kidnap Michigan governor
View
Date:2025-04-12 06:27:10
DETROIT (AP) — An appeals court is raising major questions about the trial of two key figures in a plot to kidnap Michigan’s governor — and putting federal prosecutors on the defensive as the government tries to preserve the extraordinary guilty verdicts.
After hearing arguments in May, the court took the uncommon step of asking for more written briefs on the impact of a trial judge’s decision to bar evidence that might have supported claims of entrapment made by Adam Fox and Barry Croft Jr.
Fox and Croft are in prison for leading a conspiracy to try to snatch Gov. Gretchen Whitmer in 2020. Prosecutors said a ragtag band of anti-government extremists had hoped that an abduction at her vacation home would spark a civil war around the same time as the presidential election.
Defense attorneys wanted jurors to see more communications between FBI handlers, undercover agents and paid informants who had fooled Fox and Croft and got inside the group. They argued that any plan to kidnap Whitmer was repeatedly pushed by those government actors.
But at the 2022 trial, U.S. District Judge Robert Jonker greatly restricted the use of certain text messages and audio recordings under his interpretation of evidence rules.
“Trials are about telling your story, giving your narrative, trying to persuade,” Croft’s appellate lawyer, Timothy Sweeney, told the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which posts audio on its website.
“When you’re denied the ability to use the rules of evidence where they benefit you, that is an unfair trial. ... This case needs to be reversed and sent back for a new trial for that reason,” Sweeney said.
He might have Judge Joan Larsen on his side. She was the most aggressive on the three-judge panel, at one point seeming incredulous with the government’s stance on an important legal precedent at play in the appeal.
“Oh, come on,” she told Assistant U.S. Attorney Nils Kessler. “Really?”
Larsen said defense lawyers wanted jurors to see that “government informants were just pounding” Fox and Croft.
“Make a plan, make a plan, make a plan — you’re just sitting around. You’re all talk, you’re no action, make a plan,” she said. “Surely that’s relevant.”
Kessler said any error by Jonker to keep out certain messages was harmless.
“They were talking about doing this before they ever met the informants,” he said. “Adam Fox said we need to take our tyrants as hostages two weeks before he had ever met a government informant. Barry Croft had been talking about it much longer.”
Lawyers met a Monday deadline to file additional briefs. Sweeney and co-counsel Steven Nolder said there were dozens of examples of excluded evidence that could have bolstered an entrapment defense.
The error “infested the entire trial,” they said in asking to have the convictions thrown out.
Kessler, however, said Fox and Croft didn’t need to be egged on by informants or undercover agents. He noted that weapons and bomb-making material were discovered after the FBI broke up the operation with arrests in October 2020. Whitmer, a Democrat, was never physically harmed.
The jury would not have been convinced that “Fox or Croft were ‘pushed’ against their will into conspiring to use explosives or conspiring to kidnap the governor,” Kessler said.
It’s not known when the appeals court will release an opinion. Another issue for the court is an allegation of juror bias.
Prosecutors had a mixed record in the overall investigation: There were five acquittals among 14 people charged in state or federal court. Fox, 41, and Croft, 48, were convicted at a second trial after a jury at the first trial couldn’t reach a unanimous verdict.
___
Follow Ed White on X at: https://twitter.com/edwritez
veryGood! (19)
Related
- Tom Holland's New Venture Revealed
- Sleep Better With Sheets, Mattresses, and More Bedroom Essentials for Sleep Week 2024
- Oscars 2024: Ryan Gosling Reunites With Barbie's Kens for I’m Just Ken Performance
- Robert Downey Jr. Credits His Terrible Childhood for First Oscar Win
- Working Well: When holidays present rude customers, taking breaks and the high road preserve peace
- RHOC's Alexis Bellino and John Janssen Make First Red Carpet Appearance as a Couple
- Ryan Gosling greets fans, Vanessa Hudgens debuts baby bump: The top Oscars red carpet moments
- Full transcript of Face the Nation, March 10, 2024
- Civic engagement nonprofits say democracy needs support in between big elections. Do funders agree?
- Marcia Gay Harden on a role you may not know: herself
Ranking
- Macy's says employee who allegedly hid $150 million in expenses had no major 'impact'
- 'A stunning turnabout': Voters and lawmakers across US move to reverse criminal justice reform
- What stores are open Easter 2024? See details for Target, Walmart, Home Depot, TJ Maxx
- Caitlin Clark needs a break before NCAA tournament begins
- Travis Hunter, the 2
- Who won Oscars for 2024? See the full list of Academy Award winners
- Horoscopes Today, March 9, 2024
- Brother of LSU guard Flau’jae Johnson arrested after SEC Tournament championship fight
Recommendation
The company planning a successor to Concorde makes its first supersonic test
Schools are hiring more teachers than ever. So why aren't there enough of them?
Stock market today: Asian shares mostly lower, Japan’s Nikkei 225 falls 2.5%
Which NFL team has the most salary cap space? What to know ahead of NFL free agency
'No Good Deed': Who's the killer in the Netflix comedy? And will there be a Season 2?
Billie Eilish, Ramy Youssef wear red pins for Israel-Gaza ceasefire on Oscars red carpet
Lindsay Lohan Is So Fetch at Vanity Fair Oscars After-Party for First Time in Over a Decade
South Carolina beats LSU for women's SEC championship after near-brawl, ejections